SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Cobia CLOSED
 
Notifications
Clear all

Cobia CLOSED

60 Posts
31 Users
0 Reactions
142.6 K Views
Bernie McCants
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 289
 

Sidebar:

When he said "plenty for everybody", I believe that included commercials. How many of the fish that you listed are harvested commercially?

Fish are grown out and sold commercially.

Released in the wild for the recreationals.

Didn't mention west coast salmon hatcheries which has supported red and commercial and tribal fisheries for years.

But spawning and raising cobia is well established



   
ReplyQuote
Drew Maultsby
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 806
 

Growing fish out, and selling them commercially, and spawning and raising cobia, is referred to as aquaculture I believe. It is a totally different ballgame than a hatchery supported fishery that will benefit traditional fishing methods and occupations, or heritage fishing, if you prefer.
I think the jury is still out on the long term health of the west coast salmon fishery, so let's look at our own hatchery raised, wild caught NC striped bass. How are we doing there, dollars and sense wise?
Or back to your first reply, what was the commercial take on red drum in SC, FW trout, striped bass, hybrid bass last year.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Growing fish out, and selling them commercially, and spawning and raising cobia, is referred to as aquaculture I believe. It is a totally different ballgame than a hatchery supported fishery that will benefit traditional fishing methods and occupations, or heritage fishing, if you prefer.
I think the jury is still out on the long term health of the west coast salmon fishery, so let's look at our own hatchery raised, wild caught NC striped bass. How are we doing there, dollars and sense wise?
Or back to your first reply, what was the commercial take on red drum in SC, FW trout, striped bass, hybrid bass last year.

Why shouldn't seafood consumers benefit from sustainable fisheries and maybe even contribute to them with a 1% restocking fee on seafood sales?

We need to learn from past stocking mistakes and successes. Not every fish is a good candidate for stocking. Cobia is a good one. The CCA has shown that drum, trout, and flounder can be successfully stocked through partnerships with others states. Stocking more river herring would benefit everything that eats them including those dreadful humans who think seafood should be eaten.

The sportsmen's goal of banning most commercial seafood harvest is to have more recreational opportunity. What happens when recreational harvest matches the total take we have between both sectors now? Will NOAA's prediction of mostly catch and release recreational fisheries come true as increasing regulatory and voluntary discards fill quotas due to projected discard mortality?

We need to remember that fish are food and try to secure a sustainable food supply for future generations. We have an opportunity to shift the management focus toward enhancing our fisheries and food supply rather than just restricting our freedom to access them. Why not try something that would benefit everyone while advancing individual liberties and generating additional revenue?



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
Topic starter  

If the seafood consumer is the key to your argument, wouldn't it make more sense to grow the hatchery fish to market size rather than growing them, releasing them and harvesting them again?

Seems it would be less expensive to the consumer that way

I am asking questions... I don't know squat about aquaculture/mariculture/fish farming etc.. I am interested in learning though so educate me



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

If the seafood consumer is the key to your argument, wouldn't it make more sense to grow the hatchery fish to market size rather than growing them, releasing them and harvesting them again?

Seems it would be less expensive to the consumer that way

I am asking questions... I don't know squat about aquaculture/mariculture/fish farming etc.. I am interested in learning though so educate me

Thank you for asking some great questions.

This is what I have learned from asking questions and doing some research.

Aquaculture is generally considered landlocked fish farming while mariculture is open-water fish farming.

With regards to growing hatchery fish to market size, it would require closing off massive areas of public waters to confine enough fish to meet market demand. It would also require enormous amount of feed made mostly from wild-caught fish. The excess feed and feces polluting surrounding waters are two BIG issues with mariculture. The crowded cages are breeding grounds for diseases and parasites that plague local fish populations. There is also the cruelty aspect of confining pelagic fish in crowded cages.

The key to stocking native species for wild harvest by recreational and commercial fishermen is to do it on a small scale across a large area. Existing hatcheries along our coast could easily stock billions of larval stage fry from local fish. This would keep costs down while ensuring that the surviving fish would be much healthier than if we released fingerlings.

Landlocked aquaculture and hatchery supported fisheries should both to be part of our food production system and can actually benefit each other. Hatcheries could provide fry for fish farms and stock local waters. Running hatcheries at full capacity will reduce costs for everyone. Scraps from cleaned seafood could and should be processed into aquaculture feed. This approach would feed more people and create more recreational opportunity while generating more revenue in an environmentally friendly way.



   
ReplyQuote
Michael Sapp
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 170
 

proclamation came out yesterday, North Carolina will have a cobia season!!
You can have one 36" fish per person up to 4 fish. At least I can fish 7 days a week as well.
Last year only the rich man could fish 7 days a week. I couldn't afford a charter every day!!



   
ReplyQuote
john
 john
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 214
 

raising striped bass to stock to rebuild the runs in the Neuse and Tar rivers isn't working and NCDMF shows very little interest in trying to make it work. NC Wildlife Res Commissioners adopted new rules to try and protect spawning fish when they are in inland waters making their spawning run. When the NCDMF commissioners tried to do something the Director said they couldn't.
NCDMF has fought it tooth and nail since NCWRC brought it to their attention a couple years ago that genetics work was showing that the fish in those system were almost all stocked and little/no reproduction occurring.



   
ReplyQuote
george mc donald
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 374
 

Biologist in SC have already determined and documented that stocked and
wild fish will not reproduce as stated in an earlier post... The preceived notion that we can save our fisheries by introducing released stocking fish is a pipe
dream... If we as fishermen insist on continuing to resist a shorter season,slot limits, boat limits or even a total short term moratorium on any catch of certain species we,,like it or not, IMO, are only insuring our own and our grands demise as fishers !!!!



   
ReplyQuote
john
 john
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 214
 

What species of fish are you talking about where stocked fish won't reproduce?



   
ReplyQuote
Douglas Collins
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 152
 

Can anyone tell me where we stand on this for this season. Are the state waters up to three miles open. Can we bring them to the dock or not. If we are over three miles do we put them back. I have fished for them some but never caught one. Just my son and myself so just the law for the recreational side. Thanks in advance just hard sometimes for me to keep up with all of this crap. Thought I better ask before than go out not knowing.



   
ReplyQuote
Nick
 Nick
(@seapro180)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 543
 

Can anyone tell me where we stand on this for this season. Are the state waters up to three miles open. Can we bring them to the dock or not. If we are over three miles do we put them back. I have fished for them some but never caught one. Just my son and myself so just the law for the recreational side. Thanks in advance just hard sometimes for me to keep up with all of this crap. Thought I better ask before than go out not knowing.

The short answer is as long as you stay in state waters your good to go.

HOWEVER...If you catch one in state waters and travel to federal waters with the fish and you get stopped, you then can be ticketed because it cant be proven it was caught in state and not federal waters. Your fine once you get back to the boat dock. The main thing is to not be caught in federal waters with one.



   
ReplyQuote
Douglas Collins
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 152
 

Thanks for the reply. Just wanted to know before we went.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

I would love for a rich person with the means and desire to fight it get a ticket for that, since enforcement should have to prove where you caught it, not the other way around. Innocent until proven guilty, after all.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris Milks
(@fullspecdrum)
Reputable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 226
 

I think it is worded "unlawful to possess" in federal waters, so even if you had a time stamped video of you landing the fish in state waters with an identifiable land mark in the background, you could still be ticketed if in possession in federal waters. Unfortunate, but that's how I read it... :wall:



   
ReplyQuote
Nick
 Nick
(@seapro180)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 543
 

Your exactly right. If the words unlawful possession wasnt in the written layout, one could easily get out of it. You would be ticketed probably but even without hiring a lawyer, you could easily have it thrown out. This is due to the fact that they must prove WITHOUT A SHADOW OF DOUBT that you caught it in federal waters. So unless they see you reel it in, there is nothing they can do. It will cost you to moss a days work and thats it. I know as a fact as i have serval close warden friends that have told stories and how so many poachers have gotten away because of this. They covered their asses by putting possesion in it. Now they dont have to see you do it. They just have to see you with it.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 4 / 4
Share: