SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Monsters From Jekyl...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Monsters From Jekyll Island

5 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
405 Views
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter   [#50382]

A catch share monster could be unleashed at the SAFMC meeting in Jekyll Island next month with the stroke of Roy Crabtree's pen. This Exempted Fishing Permit also revives the VMS monster. Now is the time to take a stand against these four investors who want to be east coast versions of Buddy from the Big Fish Texas show.

http://safmc.net/download/Briefing%20Book%20March%202017/TAB%2011%20Council%20Session/A8d_SAReefFishCollaborative_EFP_Request/SouthAtlanticReefFishCollaborativeEFP_Request020617.pdf



   
Quote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

Here is a message I sent to the White House at this link. https://www.whitehouse.gov/contact#page

Fishermen and seafood consumers need help stopping an attempt by a few permit holders to seize control of a significant portion of the South Atlantic snapper/grouper fishery. At the March South Atlantic Fishery Management Council meeting they will be giving guidance to the National Marine Fisheries Service Southeast Regional Administrator, Dr. Roy Crabtree about if he should unilaterally approve an Exempted Fishing Permit to proceed with a pilot program that would privatize public resources. This is opposed by the overwhelming majority of stakeholders. Many of us would like to vote on this pilot catch share program as HB 200 would allow. Unfortunately, Dr. Crabtree could approve the EFP before that bill becomes law. Please ask Dr. Crabtree to let permit holders vote to approve or deny the application. He can abide by our vote even if it is not a law.  roy.crabtree@noaa.gov
 
One of the many reasons to oppose privatizing public resources is that foreign investors could eventually own our fisheries and control our supply of American seafood. A great alternative that most stakeholders support is to simply manage quotas with appropriate possession limits and bycatch allowances to avoid extended closures and excessive discards. This would limit waste, increase efficiency, and promote the safety of fishermen at sea while providing consumers with a consistent supply of local seafood.

Please contact me with any questions. Thank you in advance for your time and help. 



   
ReplyQuote
Jason Oakes
(@bottomdollar2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 300
 

Thanks Chris.

Everyone please help with this by sending in your comments to the on-line forum for the march South Atlantic Fisheries Management Council meeting.
Below are my thoughts and suggestions:

I Jason Oakes an Unlimited snapper grouper permit holder, would like to ask the Council Members and Dr. Crabtree to decline the experimental fishing permit application submitted by Seafood Harvesters of America.

Additionally I would like to petition the council to implement a "Stop and Review" action plan, numerous seasons, trip limits, species closures, etc... have been implemented over the past decade, seemingly without any time for review of one measure before passing another.

I think most fishermen would not oppose requiring the use of some type of fish release device to send a fish back to the depths before freeing it. Although this is not a scientifically proven technique, one could naturally assume that a fish returned to a condition that it can swim rather than float upside down in the current would have a higher probability of survival.

Additionally on the matter of "catch shares", IFQ's, what ever the name of the day is, I suggest that a formal vote be taken on the issue. Each snapper grouper permit should get a vote, the recreational sector should participate also, I am not certain how to "regulate" the eligibility to vote as a recreational stakeholder. In any event, when the votes are tallied if overwhelming opposition to "catch shares" continues to be the result, the issue should not be raised again for a period of time (10 years or never?) If the vote supports "catch shares" then measures to develop a functional system, as opposed to the system that exists in the Gulf, then proceed with such. Of course it would be reasonable to require the vote be held by a secure third party source, or each vote could be on-line public record and each person can view and confirm their vote as the votes are counted.

I understand there are numerous conflicting issues the SAFMC is tasked to develop measures to resolve. All stakeholders should work together to first fully understand the issues and then work to resolve them in the best interest of developing a sustainable fish stock while allowing the greatest possible access to the resource for all stakeholders. But I feel that this effort should not include a continuous and seemingly endless list of new regulations and amendments.

Thank You

Jason Oakes
Atlantic Coast Seafood Co. Inc.

I will also add that I have had several very positive conversations with Dr. Michelle Duvall Chairperson of the SAFMC.
She and I agreed completely on several topics and had some similar thoughts and some dis-similar thoughts on other topics, but we had several conversations exchanging thoughts and questions towards developing a sustainable fishery.
I encourage everyone to do the same with their regional representative.

To that point, Charlie Phillips and I previously had a couple good conversations, we actually agreed on all topics discussed except catch shares, but conversation was had. He and I both agreed that we could speak harshly to one another and neither one would have any problem doing so, but no information would be shared and no possible solutions will ever be developed by such conversations.
All stakeholders should try to engage in similar conversations.

In the on-line comment section, there was an unlimited snapper grouper permit holder that condemned the EFP application and in the same sentence agreed that part time fishermen should be booted out, WHAT?
Due to the sheer circumstances of seasonal closures that currently exists, everyone that commercial fishes is part time, or "laid off" for certain times of the year, there isn't a continuously open fishery in the South Atlantic that I'm aware of, in NC at least, with the weather variable to contend with especially.

We should work together and stop throwing each other "under the buss" Recreational vs. commercial vs. full time vs. part time (whatever part time means I'm not making payments on a part time unlimited snapper grouper permit) isn't going to help any cause except the environmentalists cause to eventually ban fishing if we cannot stand together to support access to the resource. Because you had better believe the environmentalists are united to ban hunting, fishing, bull riding, you name it!

I also sent two comments to the link to the white house that Chris provided above.
I simply asked the President and Vice President to consider reviewing the NOAA marine fisheries division, particularly the South East Regional Office, to see if the constant regulations coming from that office meets the white houses' criteria of regulations that restricts business opportunities and growth in America.

Also I intend over the next several days to contact my US representatives to ask their support of:

H.R.200 — 115th Congress (2017-2018)
Strengthening Fishing Communities and Increasing Flexibility in Fisheries Management Act

Jason Oakes



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

Great post and comments BottomDollar2. Thank you! Your actions and those of many others is making a difference. Enough people getting involved is the only thing that will stop this latest attack on our freedom to fish. Silence equals passive support for catch shares.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

March 2017 SAFMC Meeting Public Comments

I am Chris McCaffity, an independent commercial fisherman and fisheries advocate. I have already submitted public comments on most of the agenda items so these comments will focus on OPPOSITION to the Exempted Fishing Permit application and offering alternative solutions that would be more beneficial for the fish, fishermen, fishery managers, and seafood consumers.

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme may help end overfishing. 
Quotas end overfishing. Allocations privatize public resources.

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme may prevent/reduce ACL overages.
Appropriate possession limits and/or Bycatch Allowances for the final portion of quotas currently experiencing early closures would prevent/reduce ACL overages without privatizing our public resources.

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme will reduce discards and discard mortality.
Privatizing our public resources will do nothing to reduce discard mortality and could still result in regulatory discards if the investor pool of shares runs out before the end of a season. Descending Devices are proven to reduce discard mortality. Appropriate possession limits and/or Bycatch Allowances reduce regulatory discards for everyone.

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme will improve landing and discard accounting.
Commercial landings is already the most accurate data the council has and we should focus more on reducing regulatory discards than calculating them.  

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme will achieve a year-round fishery.
Allocations will provide an incentive for shareholders to target legal fish that aren't part of their pilot program to save their shares for when those fisheries are closed. The investor pool of shares could still be landed before the end of a fishing year resulting in an early closure. This multi-species fishery should be managed so almost everything is legal most of the time. Appropriate possession limits and/or Bycatch Allowances would allow fishermen to target fish with higher limits while still keeping most of what we accidentally catch with lower limits. This simple solution would bring the council into compliance with Magnuson-Stevens Act mandates to limit waste, make efficient use of our resources, and promote the safety of fishermen at sea.    

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme will improve the profitability of fishing businesses through flexibility of fishing.
Properly managing quotas with appropriate possession limits and/or Bycatch Allowances would achieve this without privatizing our public resources.

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme will increase fishery stability.
Catch Shares/IFQs/ITQs or whatever Environmental Defense Fund is calling their allocation scheme today have a record of decreasing fishery stability for all but the few permit holders who are willing to sell everyone else out for personal gain.

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme will retain fleet characteristics.
Privatizing public resources has a record of disproportionately hurting independent owner/operators who are the backbone of traditional fishing fleets.   

The EFP applicants claim their allocation scheme will increase capacity for and support of industry involvement in management.
Approving this application will undermine any confidence fishermen have left in the management process and make stakeholders less likely to work with fishery managers on the Visioning Project and Citizen Science Program.

The EFP applicants say their allocation scheme will allow for a comparative socio-economic analysis between existing commercial fishing regulations and their allocation scheme. 
Fishermen expressed frustration with existing regulations and a desire for better quota management at the Visioning Project port meetings. The Visioning Project should be where stakeholders discuss different management options to decide what would work best for our fishery. Approving this EFP would undermine the Visioning Project and all the hard work that has already gone into it.  

The EFP applicants say their allocation scheme will allow them to test the effectiveness in providing accurate, near real-time catch and effort data through an electronic data collection system.
This is something most fishermen support and should be addressed in the Visioning Project or Citizen Science Program.

The EFP applicants say their allocation scheme will let them test the administrative aspects of catch shares in the South Atlantic, including Vessel Monitoring Systems and tracking/transfer of shares/allocations.
The council's limited resources could be put to much better use than tracking the transfer of shares for the personal gain of a few investors. The VMS corporations must make some significant contributions to EDF for them to keep pushing those outdated spy devices. The overwhelming majority of stakeholders have repeatedly opposed VMS in several amendments. The only stakeholders who support VMS are those colluding with EDF to seize control of our fishery.

I was going to go through the entire application this way, but haven't even made it through three of the 18 pages. These comments and those that many others have submitted sufficiently make a compelling case that clearly shows this EFP is the wrong way to go. Here are a few more points that anyone who is still unsure should consider. The EFP would circumvent spawning season protections. The four applicants/permit holders have had years to pad their landings history by sending their captains to specifically target the fish listed in their application. Foreign investors could eventually control some privatized fisheries and restrict American citizen's freedom to access our public resources. Regardless of how benign this EFP may seem to some, there is far too much potential for it to morph into something we will regret or be able to reverse.  

I respectfully ask the council and Dr. Crabtree to reject the application. If there is any doubt that the overwhelming majority of stakeholders oppose this EFP, please let us vote on it as HB 200 would allow. The council's Visioning Project and Citizen Science Program are the right places to discuss quota management and data collection ideas.

I am happy to answer any questions or go into greater detail about why approving the Exempted Fishing Permit is such a bad idea that would undermine the National Marine Fisheries Service and South Atlantic Fishery Management Council's credibility.



   
ReplyQuote
Share: