SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
The pew bots at safmc just announced that there will not be a red snapper season in the Atlantic this year
Bastards.
Toad is being far to kind with his brief comment!
Sucks. Not surprised unfortunately. Just read the email.
Did you guys think about the numbers they used/manipulated/made up? They use fish instead of pounds to avoid saying we accidentally killed approximately 1,500,000 pounds of rare Red Snapper last year. That means we were forced to discard well over 3 MILLION pounds of Red Snapper by-catch.
Did you guys think about the numbers they used/manipulated/made up? They use fish instead of pounds to avoid saying we accidentally killed approximately 1,500,000 pounds of rare Red Snapper last year. That means we were forced to discard well over 3 MILLION pounds of Red Snapper by-catch.
I thought about it. But isn't that the way they are counting down in the Gulf. Looks like everything in the gulf that comes over the rail commercially goes in the box? Correct me if I'm wrong.
Did you guys think about the numbers they used/manipulated/made up? They use fish instead of pounds to avoid saying we accidentally killed approximately 1,500,000 pounds of rare Red Snapper last year. That means we were forced to discard well over 3 MILLION pounds of Red Snapper by-catch.
I noticed that. I find it hard to believe that red snapper are SO RARE that:
Recs accidentally caught a quarter of a million of them and that the agenda driven knuckleheads declare that every one of them died
Every one I caught swam off healthy and unharmed but according to the PEWBOTS at safmc, that didn't really happen
Remember when the fisheries scientists were interested in real science?
What mortality rate are they using for recreational releases?
And how are they calculating the number of fish caught/released recreationally? I have never been asked how many I released...
This is somewhat of a punishment for not embracing catch shares. Same with MPA/SMZ area closures.
They assume a 40% mortality rate and assume each fishermen discards x number of snapper every trip. Government data and science at it's agenda driven best!
So is the starting point is Saltwater license holders?
Then they start making assumptions?
Does anyone know the actual calculations? What % of license holders do they assume go bottom fishing, how many trips per year, and how many red snapper are released per trip?
This is somewhat of a punishment for not embracing catch shares. Same with MPA/SMZ area closures.
Punishment from who?
I ask because the MS act is very rigid and does not leave much flexibility for management of stock rebuilding.
Do you think the continuation of the red snapper closure is truly punishment or is this a function of a rigid law the council is forced to abide to?
This is somewhat of a punishment for not embracing catch shares. Same with MPA/SMZ area closures.
Punishment from who?
I ask because the MS act is very rigid and does not leave much flexibility for management of stock rebuilding.
Do you think the continuation of the red snapper closure is truly punishment or is this a function of a rigid law the council is forced to abide to?
They use the law as an excuse to shut down fisheries.
They did it with sea bass, vermillion snapper, red snapper, grouper etc..
First they start with a purely fictional guess on what the pristine stocks looked like, then they enter it into a computer model that compares what that purely fictional stock was vs. current wild guesses about landings.
When the purely fictional guess is entered into a computer model, compounded with purely fabricated landings guesses, the outcome is a fishery on the verge of extinction (which is exactly what these pewbots want it to look like)
When confronted with better science that is more realistic (underwater video for example), the council hides behind MSA and claims what they are using is the "best available".
Completely ignore the fact that the one model is the ONLY data they looked at because if you only look at one option only it is considered the best available and MSA requires best available.
So, in a long winded round about way.. the council is using bad data to manufacture a crisis that does not exist, using flawed methodology with the bad data to "prove" the crisis and then once confronted with real facts, they will claim the fishery is recovered and they are to thank for it.
Look no further than the black sea bass debacle from a few years ago..
This is somewhat of a punishment for not embracing catch shares. Same with MPA/SMZ area closures.
Punishment from who?
I ask because the MS act is very rigid and does not leave much flexibility for management of stock rebuilding.
Do you think the continuation of the red snapper closure is truly punishment or is this a function of a rigid law the council is forced to abide to?
They use the law as an excuse to shut down fisheries.
They did it with sea bass, vermillion snapper, red snapper, grouper etc..
First they start with a purely fictional guess on what the pristine stocks looked like, then they enter it into a computer model that compares what that purely fictional stock was vs. current wild guesses about landings.
When the purely fictional guess is entered into a computer model, compounded with purely fabricated landings guesses, the outcome is a fishery on the verge of extinction (which is exactly what these pewbots want it to look like)
When confronted with better science that is more realistic (underwater video for example), the council hides behind MSA and claims what they are using is the "best available".
Completely ignore the fact that the one model is the ONLY data they looked at because if you only look at one option only it is considered the best available and MSA requires best available.
So, in a long winded round about way.. the council is using bad data to manufacture a crisis that does not exist, using flawed methodology with the bad data to "prove" the crisis and then once confronted with real facts, they will claim the fishery is recovered and they are to thank for it.
Look no further than the black sea bass debacle from a few years ago..
I understand the frustrations. I experience them too.... and don't get me wrong. My engagement here is not to take up for the council or to make accusations based upon data that may or may not be true.
I would like to think out loud for a second. All comments welcome. Even attacks.
1 -Why would Anna Beckwith, Michelle Duvall, Jack Cox (don't know if he still holds his seat), Chris Conklin, Mark Brown, allow such a thing to happen? I am talking about punishment here. Why would they punish us. Why would they want the fishery to remain closed? I am asking this objectively. I am looking for facts here and not speculative assumptions based upon heresay. (I realize that two of the above voted for catch shares)
2 - The law directs rigid management to implement non scientifically based mandates, (ie, rebuild within 10 years, 2 years to establish a rebuilding plan after an overfished assessment, etc.) How could new council members or new politicians make a difference without a wholesale change to the MSA? Would this not explain the lack of progress from council members that are pro rec like Anna Beckwith and Mark Brown?
3 - If you think the continuation of the red snapper closure for 2016 sucks, wait until SAFMC releases the red snapper data SEDAR 41. = 90 ft + closure?
My point with the above thoughts is this: The council does the same thing year after year regardless of membership. Take, take, take. If they can not do anything to change the course we are on. Who can?
I don't have all of the answers to your questions, but I do have a few..
First, wrt to council members. There is one person (possibly two) you listed that took money from PEW to push catch shares and then miraculously changed their positions from opposing to supporting catch shares. Look into it. His/her business interest would be wildly more profitable once he owned exclusive access via catch shares.
Second, the 90 foot closure has been something they have been trying to force for decades. Cupka tried it so many times I can't even count that high. It has been met with resistance each time so they modify something else and end up closing incrementally. Change the shape of MPAs to encompass more areas, special spawning area closures, special season closures, ridiculously high discard mortality estimates, limits so small that people stop fishing etc..
The council is in the pockets of PEW environmental group. They gave up on objectivity a long time ago. I am very surprised that Capt. Mark Brown has not made a bigger impact and I do not why. He is a vocal champion for science based management for both the recreational and commercial sectors. Maybe his relative newness on the council has something to do with it, or maybe the pew funded sellouts are simply drowning out his voice. I don't know what's going on and honestly I have grown so disgusted by this group that I stopped paying attention to their antics
One of the members also spent years with EDF.