SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
This is somewhat of a punishment for not embracing catch shares. Same with MPA/SMZ area closures.
Punishment from who?
I ask because the MS act is very rigid and does not leave much flexibility for management of stock rebuilding.
Do you think the continuation of the red snapper closure is truly punishment or is this a function of a rigid law the council is forced to abide to?
They use the law as an excuse to shut down fisheries.
They did it with sea bass, vermillion snapper, red snapper, grouper etc..
First they start with a purely fictional guess on what the pristine stocks looked like, then they enter it into a computer model that compares what that purely fictional stock was vs. current wild guesses about landings.
When the purely fictional guess is entered into a computer model, compounded with purely fabricated landings guesses, the outcome is a fishery on the verge of extinction (which is exactly what these pewbots want it to look like)
When confronted with better science that is more realistic (underwater video for example), the council hides behind MSA and claims what they are using is the "best available".
Completely ignore the fact that the one model is the ONLY data they looked at because if you only look at one option only it is considered the best available and MSA requires best available.
So, in a long winded round about way.. the council is using bad data to manufacture a crisis that does not exist, using flawed methodology with the bad data to "prove" the crisis and then once confronted with real facts, they will claim the fishery is recovered and they are to thank for it.
Look no further than the black sea bass debacle from a few years ago..
I understand the frustrations. I experience them too.... and don't get me wrong. My engagement here is not to take up for the council or to make accusations based upon data that may or may not be true.
I would like to think out loud for a second. All comments welcome. Even attacks.
1 -Why would Anna Beckwith, Michelle Duvall, Jack Cox (don't know if he still holds his seat), Chris Conklin, Mark Brown, allow such a thing to happen? I am talking about punishment here. Why would they punish us. Why would they want the fishery to remain closed? I am asking this objectively. I am looking for facts here and not speculative assumptions based upon heresay. (I realize that two of the above voted for catch shares)
2 - The law directs rigid management to implement non scientifically based mandates, (ie, rebuild within 10 years, 2 years to establish a rebuilding plan after an overfished assessment, etc.) How could new council members or new politicians make a difference without a wholesale change to the MSA? Would this not explain the lack of progress from council members that are pro rec like Anna Beckwith and Mark Brown?
3 - If you think the continuation of the red snapper closure for 2016 sucks, wait until SAFMC releases the red snapper data SEDAR 41. = 90 ft + closure?
My point with the above thoughts is this: The council does the same thing year after year regardless of membership. Take, take, take. If they can not do anything to change the course we are on. Who can?
These are good questions and Squid Row did a good job answering. I'll do my best to answer each question and hope the discussion continues.
"Punishment from who?"
From what I have learned the agenda and punishment are coming from a few powerful people in the SAFMC and NMFS that are being guided by the IUCN/NOAA/ENGO cabal.
"Do you think the continuation of the red snapper closure is truly punishment or is this a function of a rigid law the council is forced to abide to?"
Those advancing the IUCN/NOAA/ENGO agenda pick and choose which parts of the MSA they will or will not use and manipulate the data as Squid Row indicated to achieve a desired outcome. I think we could keep some Red Snapper if they were "managed" with some version of catch shares. Warsaw Grouper and Speckled Hind are "managed"with catch shares in the gulf and they get to keep them while we get a total ban on all harvest and area closures even though SH and WG are considered to be the same stocks in the gulf and east coast.
"Why would Anna Beckwith, Michelle Duvall, Jack Cox (don't know if he still holds his seat), Chris Conklin, Mark Brown, allow such a thing to happen? I am talking about punishment here. Why would they punish us. Why would they want the fishery to remain closed?"
They are being manipulated by those pushing the agenda. Some feel just as frustrated as we do. Most council members aren't maliciously trying to hurt us.
"The law directs rigid management to implement non scientifically based mandates, (ie, rebuild within 10 years, 2 years to establish a rebuilding plan after an overfished assessment, etc.) How could new council members or new politicians make a difference without a wholesale change to the MSA? Would this not explain the lack of progress from council members that are pro rec like Anna Beckwith and Mark Brown?"
It is almost impossible for any one council member or politician to change things. The only way we can change things is for enough fishermen, seafood consumers, and concerned citizens to coordinate our message and efforts.
" If you think the continuation of the red snapper closure for 2016 sucks, wait until SAFMC releases the red snapper data SEDAR 41. = 90 ft + closure?"
The lack of data during this prolonged closure will allow SEDAR 41 to be more easily manipulated to show a desired result that will be used to push for more laws restricting our freedom to fish.
"My point with the above thoughts is this: The council does the same thing year after year regardless of membership. Take, take, take. If they can not do anything to change the course we are on. Who can?"
The only way we can change things is for enough fishermen, seafood consumers, and concerned citizens to coordinate our message and efforts. Discussions like this are a good start. Knowledge is POWER and we have POWER in numbers.
This is somewhat of a punishment for not embracing catch shares. Same with MPA/SMZ area closures.
Punishment from who?
I ask because the MS act is very rigid and does not leave much flexibility for management of stock rebuilding.
Do you think the continuation of the red snapper closure is truly punishment or is this a function of a rigid law the council is forced to abide to?
They use the law as an excuse to shut down fisheries.
They did it with sea bass, vermillion snapper, red snapper, grouper etc..
First they start with a purely fictional guess on what the pristine stocks looked like, then they enter it into a computer model that compares what that purely fictional stock was vs. current wild guesses about landings.
When the purely fictional guess is entered into a computer model, compounded with purely fabricated landings guesses, the outcome is a fishery on the verge of extinction (which is exactly what these pewbots want it to look like)
When confronted with better science that is more realistic (underwater video for example), the council hides behind MSA and claims what they are using is the "best available".
Completely ignore the fact that the one model is the ONLY data they looked at because if you only look at one option only it is considered the best available and MSA requires best available.
So, in a long winded round about way.. the council is using bad data to manufacture a crisis that does not exist, using flawed methodology with the bad data to "prove" the crisis and then once confronted with real facts, they will claim the fishery is recovered and they are to thank for it.
Look no further than the black sea bass debacle from a few years ago..
I understand the frustrations. I experience them too.... and don't get me wrong. My engagement here is not to take up for the council or to make accusations based upon data that may or may not be true.
I would like to think out loud for a second. All comments welcome. Even attacks.
1 -Why would Anna Beckwith, Michelle Duvall, Jack Cox (don't know if he still holds his seat), Chris Conklin, Mark Brown, allow such a thing to happen? I am talking about punishment here. Why would they punish us. Why would they want the fishery to remain closed? I am asking this objectively. I am looking for facts here and not speculative assumptions based upon heresay. (I realize that two of the above voted for catch shares)
2 - The law directs rigid management to implement non scientifically based mandates, (ie, rebuild within 10 years, 2 years to establish a rebuilding plan after an overfished assessment, etc.) How could new council members or new politicians make a difference without a wholesale change to the MSA? Would this not explain the lack of progress from council members that are pro rec like Anna Beckwith and Mark Brown?
3 - If you think the continuation of the red snapper closure for 2016 sucks, wait until SAFMC releases the red snapper data SEDAR 41. = 90 ft + closure?
My point with the above thoughts is this: The council does the same thing year after year regardless of membership. Take, take, take. If they can not do anything to change the course we are on. Who can?
These are good questions and Squid Row did a good job answering. I'll do my best to answer each question and hope the discussion continues.
"Punishment from who?"
From what I have learned the agenda and punishment are coming from a few powerful people in the SAFMC and NMFS that are being guided by the IUCN/NOAA/ENGO cabal.
"Do you think the continuation of the red snapper closure is truly punishment or is this a function of a rigid law the council is forced to abide to?"
Those advancing the IUCN/NOAA/ENGO agenda pick and choose which parts of the MSA they will or will not use and manipulate the data as Squid Row indicated to achieve a desired outcome. I think we could keep some Red Snapper if they were "managed" with some version of catch shares. Warsaw Grouper and Speckled Hind are "managed"with catch shares in the gulf and they get to keep them while we get a total ban on all harvest and area closures even though SH and WG are considered to be the same stocks in the gulf and east coast.
"Why would Anna Beckwith, Michelle Duvall, Jack Cox (don't know if he still holds his seat), Chris Conklin, Mark Brown, allow such a thing to happen? I am talking about punishment here. Why would they punish us. Why would they want the fishery to remain closed?"
They are being manipulated by those pushing the agenda. Some feel just as frustrated as we do. Most council members aren't maliciously trying to hurt us.
"The law directs rigid management to implement non scientifically based mandates, (ie, rebuild within 10 years, 2 years to establish a rebuilding plan after an overfished assessment, etc.) How could new council members or new politicians make a difference without a wholesale change to the MSA? Would this not explain the lack of progress from council members that are pro rec like Anna Beckwith and Mark Brown?"
It is almost impossible for any one council member or politician to change things. The only way we can change things is for enough fishermen, seafood consumers, and concerned citizens to coordinate our message and efforts.
" If you think the continuation of the red snapper closure for 2016 sucks, wait until SAFMC releases the red snapper data SEDAR 41. = 90 ft + closure?"
The lack of data during this prolonged closure will allow SEDAR 41 to be more easily manipulated to show a desired result that will be used to push for more laws restricting our freedom to fish.
"My point with the above thoughts is this: The council does the same thing year after year regardless of membership. Take, take, take. If they can not do anything to change the course we are on. Who can?"
The only way we can change things is for enough fishermen, seafood consumers, and concerned citizens to coordinate our message and efforts. Discussions like this are a good start. Knowledge is POWER and we have POWER in numbers.
Thank you to you and Squid Row for the reply.
I asked the questions above to show a particular point. Which you reinforced, I agree the council members "aren't maliciously trying to hurt us" ( as you stated above) but it was also stated above about "punishment". Which is contradictory.
Which brings me to:
There seems to always be a big bad boogie man with a negative agenda standing over the council dictating their actions. (I say this in a non condescending way). All of the questions I ask always go back to a dark force trying to remove all fishermen from the water. Every single time.
and there may be such groups that want that
but I have yet to see any documentation or fact that such a dark force manipulates the council.
Chris - I know you have been involved with SAFMC for quite some time. Citizen Science...etc. and I have witnessed your public comments at meetings.(I think that was you. Do you have long hair pulled back?) You probably have quite a bit more info on the inner workings than I do due to your experience with the council. That is why I raise the question. Do you have evidence that such a dark force with a dark agenda seeks to systematically remove fishermen from the ocean?
I ask this question because I want to know and educate myself.
Everything I have researched thus far, including some very candid conversation with former council members and current SAFMC staff, is that MSA and the NEPA process have a harder influence upon these measures than a dark force with a dark agenda.
For instance, the NEPA process for the development of amendments and their associated effects, have strict guidelines that could very easily lead to litigation if proper alternatives and effects are not considered. Socioeconomic impacts are one example. These things simply can not be ignored. To be sure RFA and the sustainable fishing crew have a lawyer to review this. (Maybe they should hire S. E. Law Center LOL)
Now, if there is ever any proof of manipulation of the NEPA process to steer a to a particular outcome, you could blow up SAFMC with one swift blow (from litigation).
It is my opinion that SAFMC will continue this course until the MSA changes. No doubt that groups with a lobby and $$$ try and manipulate things for a particular agenda, but in the case studies I have found (thus far), their efforts went into oversight that MSA law was being followed appropriately instead of trying to remove recreational anglers and commercial fishermen.
So I ask, and please forgive if it sounds skeptical, but I want to learn, do you have any hard evidence... of any organization or government agency, that is manipulating any of the SAFMC to advance a dark agenda?
Is there a case study, document, law suit, anything other than heresay?
Just an FYI - I am trying to learn here not discredit or start a fight.
For added discussion though.....
Check this out
Go back to the last SAFMC meeting..... Day 5, full council session audio... Listen from 1:36:00 until 2:05:40 and again from 3:15:00 until 3:21:10. Any of that sound concerning? Especially from a council member that holds a rec seat (georgia member)?
Could this be the dark agenda coming out into public view?
WhiteLakeBuc, that was me you described. Thanks for keeping the discussion going.
There isn't one big bad boogie man calling all the shots that I know of. Look into the IUCN membership list to see all the government and non-government organizations working together to shape policies for managing/controlling natural resources across the globe. http://www.iucn.org/about/union/members/
Federal fishery management is a good example of mostly well-intentioned public servants unwittingly unleashing the "evils of bureaucracy" on us. Those with less than honorable intentions guide/manipulate the others to implement the IUCN policies.
Do you have a link to the referenced council session audio?
I have followed Catch Shares and anything related since before it had a name. I can tell everyone who the boogie man was and still is. It is special interest groups (green groups, corporations, etc). What everyone is seeing take place is and has taken place in climate, energy, communications, foreign policy, domestic social policy and now fisheries. Certain groups, regardless of what their cause or interest are/ were, organize themselves and more importantly fund themselves to the extent they gain political influence. Once the donations are made they then expect their bidding be done. Since we are talking about fisheries, put the focus on political appointments to begin with in conjunction with political "donations". Trace the movement of individuals (appointments) from the original groups, PEW, EDF, Oceana, Green Peace, Sierra Club, etc. but namely EDF and PEW. Then look at their ties to all powerful NOAA and subsidiaries of NOAA. Then watch how the law is written and /or interpreted from that point on. And more importantly, look at the funding; primarily government funding influenced by private "donations" from the groups previously mentioned. Eventually the philosophy and interpretation of law trickles down to the councils, and so do some of the people. What you are left with is corrupted members. Some who already serve the master and some who talked an honest game but are either forced out or come to tow the line. Though I can't prove it, I think some of the individuals end-up being bought so their ties are actually trivial (commercial v/s recreational ties). Then comes the most interesting and troubling part; the fact that the government mandates are from these special interests groups via government subsidiary intermediaries (primarily NOAA and NOAA subsidiaries) and Congress never actually legislated what is being enforced. In some cases, and in the case of fisheries, the law (magnuson) is referenced as the new philosophy/ desire is interjected to serve the interests of certain people and groups. It can and does go all the way to the White House if you trace the people back. More interesting to, is the government funding. Choose not to tow the line, jeopardize your funding and risk replacement. And finally, once the toe hold is put in place, the even bigger money moves in to capitalize. This is where people in government and on councils and committees straight up get paid off either monetarily, a monopoly is provided, or other forms of exclusivity. So now we have a rush to capitalize with a disregard to the resource, communities, etc. Just follow the people and the money as they get their talking points and observe how quickly things get reshaped.
WhiteLakeBuc, that was me you described. Thanks for keeping the discussion going.
There isn't one big bad boogie man calling all the shots that I know of. Look into the IUCN membership list to see all the government and non-government organizations working together to shape policies for managing/controlling natural resources across the globe. http://www.iucn.org/about/union/members/
Federal fishery management is a good example of mostly well-intentioned public servants unwittingly unleashing the "evils of bureaucracy" on us. Those with less than honorable intentions guide/manipulate the others to implement the IUCN policies.
Do you have a link to the referenced council session audio?
No link, I have the recording on my hard drive. PM me an email address and I will Dropbox it or get you a cloud link.
PM sent WhiteLakeBuc. You mentioned NEPA being used against us. It can also work for us IF enough of us coordinated our efforts. NEPA and SEPA allow stakeholders to offer solutions for mitigating negative impacts of environmental regulations. We don't even have to go to court for them to work in our favor.
Good summary of the problem Matador. Now we need to think about how to make the process work for us. The ONLY thing that trumps corporate money in politics is enough people peacefully supporting or opposing an issue. Look at VMS. We could stop the SMZ area closures IF enough of us wanted to. We could also have a Red Snapper fishery next year if enough of us want it enough to do more than just complain.
WhiteLakeBuc, that was me you described. Thanks for keeping the discussion going.
There isn't one big bad boogie man calling all the shots that I know of. Look into the IUCN membership list to see all the government and non-government organizations working together to shape policies for managing/controlling natural resources across the globe. http://www.iucn.org/about/union/members/
Federal fishery management is a good example of mostly well-intentioned public servants unwittingly unleashing the "evils of bureaucracy" on us. Those with less than honorable intentions guide/manipulate the others to implement the IUCN policies.
Do you have a link to the referenced council session audio?
No link, I have the recording on my hard drive. PM me an email address and I will Dropbox it or get you a cloud link.
Just got done listening to the file you sent. A few things stand out.
1. Capping/limiting/reducing effort is a top priority.
2. Catch shares are still on the table.
3. The council is rushing to do too many things that are not required by the MSA to be done within a set time frame.
4. Robert's Rules of Order is an outdated way to debate that keeps our rulers in business. The internet gives us the power to self-govern with MSA guidelines.