SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

SAFMC Regulatory Am...
 
Notifications
Clear all

SAFMC Regulatory Amendment 29 Public Comment

6 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
192 Views
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter   [#54158]

SAFMC Regulatory Amendment 29 Public Comment

This amendment is another welcome step in the right direction that shows the council is listening to fishermen’s concerns. One key component that should be included in this process is reviewing size and trip limits to determine if they are accomplishing desired goals. We should work to manage quotas so regulatory discards are rare. The fewer fish that fishermen are required to discard, the more likely they are to help them survive. We should encourage the use of proven tools like descending devices by rewarding fishermen who use them rather than punishing those that don’t. Other management councils have successfully used this approach. The Citizen Science Program provides a wonderful opportunity to work with and reward fishermen who are willing to use descending devices when needed.

Here are my answers to some of the council’s questions.

1. How often have you seen fish with barotrauma when fishing for snapper grouper species?

We try to avoid illegal fish. Most of the fish we release can swim and look like they will live. We rarely need to use a descending device since less than 5% of the fish we release require assistance. I would be happy to tag released fish to help collect data on survival rates.

2. Are you familiar with venting devices? Descending devices? Do you use them while fishing? If not, why?

Yes, I am familiar with both. We use a descending device because they are proven to greatly increase survival rates of fish experiencing barotrauma. Venting tools are not nearly as good because they do some harm even when used correctly.

3. Are many recreational and commercial fishermen using these devices?

More and more fishermen are realizing how well descending devices work and that they are easy to use. The council could help encourage more fishermen to use descending devices by sharing information about how and when to use different devices including a barbless hook and weight that easily sends bloated fish home. Rewarding fishermen with higher quotas as discard mortality allocations are reduced based on voluntary compliance would also help encourage more fishermen to use some sort of descending device. Nobody really wants to watch a discarded fish float off to slowly die if there is an easy way to help them live.

4. Should the South Atlantic Council require recreational and/or commercial fishermen to carry descending devices and/or venting devices on board?

No, the council should encourage use with rewards rather than forcibly requiring compliance. We need to be very careful about writing laws that cause our military to push the limits of Posse Comitatus.

5. If so, how should venting devices and descending devices be defined?

Neither should be required. Descending devices should be defined as anything that can safely release a fish deep enough to recompress expanded gases.

6. Should the South Atlantic Council require fishermen to use circle hooks when fishing for snapper grouper species?

No, studies show they can do more harm than good. Using a dehooker to remove circle hooks can break the fish’s jaw. Triggerfish have such small mouths that circle hooks do not work well for catching them. Encouraging fishermen to cut the line when hooks are deep would be better than requiring circle hooks. Again, we should manage quotas to make it rare that fishermen are forced to discard illegal fish.

7. Are there species or areas that wouldn’t benefit from circle hooks?

Yes, there is not enough evidence showing circle hooks significantly benefit any fish in federal waters. Fishermen would benefit from not having to use circle hooks to catch triggerfish.

8. Should the Council require non-offset circle hooks?

No.

9. Where should circle hook use be required?

Nowhere.

10. Should the South Atlantic Council specify allowable rigs for the recreational snapper grouper fishery?

No.

11. Is there a certain depth at which using single hook rigs would help avoid dead discards?

The council should ask fishermen not to use more hooks than the limit of fish they can keep.

Please think about using more carrots than sticks. Most fishermen want to be good stewards of our marine resources. A little education and encouragement can be more effective than confusing laws that are hard to enforce.

I am always happy to answer any questions and/or go into greater detail.

Thank you,
Chris McCaffity



   
Quote
Jason Dunkley
(@jdunk)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 413
 

IMO you hit the nail on the head sir. Well Stated. Appreciate the amount of knowledge you share with us all on the snapper regs as well as keeping us uptated on the amendments that are made. Are They keeping numbers for ARS like last year? haven't been back to the site or even remember it.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

IMO you hit the nail on the head sir. Well Stated. Appreciate the amount of knowledge you share with us all on the snapper regs as well as keeping us uptated on the amendments that are made. Are They keeping numbers for ARS like last year? haven't been back to the site or even remember it.

Thank you! Here is the MY Fish Count link.

https://www.myfishcount.com/

Looks like more fishermen are using it this year. Accurate landings data helps everyone. Assumptions apply the precautionary principle that results in shorter seasons.



   
ReplyQuote
Phil
 Phil
(@boalpd)
Trusted Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 42
 

I bought my fish descender for only $20. It’s simple and sturdy and I think any bottom fisherman should carry one. See fish saver @ Roy’s electric reels.com



   
ReplyQuote
Jason Dunkley
(@jdunk)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 413
 

I bought my fish descender for only $20. It’s simple and sturdy and I think any bottom fisherman should carry one. See fish saver @ Roy’s electric reels.com

X2, I will check it out. I vent every undersize grouper released or ARS currently. But this will be a much safer release method for a cheap price. I also saw on youtube people skin hooking them with a 3-4lb weight so they pull free easly once they equalize pressure. not sure which is the best method but I will definitely check it out. Thanks for the link



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

Using a barbless hook through the skin of a fish's lip is a cheap and effective option anyone can afford. Send them to the bottom and give a little slack to see if they will shake off the hook. If not, a quick jerk will pull it free. Most fish caught in 120' or less can swim and should be released without doing anything. You can usually tell if they are too bloated to swim. Protruding stomach as a good indicator they need some help. Please let the SAFMC know you are using a descending device.



   
ReplyQuote
Share: