SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Southern Flounder
 
Notifications
Clear all

Southern Flounder

15 Posts
6 Users
0 Reactions
629 Views
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
Topic starter   [#42902]

Pulled from 'another site'.

Chuck Laughridge

My thanks to the site for allowing me to address some Southern Flounder issues.

The Marine Fisheries Commission has, after being advised of So Flounder data that shows our stocks are in a tough spot, as if most of y'all didn't already know that. Upwards of 85% of our So Flounder are being removed from the stock before spawning even one time and our commercial & recreational fisheries are dominated by SMALL (12 to 15 inch fish) that we now know don't spawn til they reach 15/16 inches.

In Feb's MFC meeting we directed Dr Louis Daniel to request that the Sec van deer Vart of DENR allow us to implement a Supplement to the So Flounder Fisheries Mgmt Plan and the the Secretary approved that. The Supplement will impose reductions in catch (includes the takes and regulatory discards that do have projected mortality) in both commercial and recreational of 25 to 60%.

There have been posts on numerous social media sites that have presented opinions that have been missing some facts that seem to have been omitted to create an angst that isn't warranted, and these posts may be from either not knowing the facts or misrepresenting them. There is quite enough misinformation about fisheries issues, from both sides of the boat, so please be sure you're informed and updated on the truth and reason for any changes to current regulations that may come.

The MFC will do the following:
1. Review data at our May meeting in New Bern on ways to reduce catch (see definition above) in the So Flounder Fishery, the range may be narrowed down or left as is.
2. Once the MFC has seen and discussed the data, it will be put into a form (written/slide show/et) and be sent out for public comment within 30 days of our May meeting.
3. The MFC will act on implementing the Supplement at the August meeting in Raleigh or status quo will remain intact.

The MFC encourages and welcomes public input and comments by phone, email, and in person at the MFC Public Comment on Wed evening and Thursday morning at every meeting. You can also make the same type of public comment at the Northern/Southern & Finfish Advisory Cmtte meetings, and you're encouraged to do so.

All the MFC member contacts are on the DENR webpage (just Google/search NC Marine Fisheries), and all the upcoming meetings are listed as well. The MFC meeting is broadcast live over the internet.

Please let us know if you want YOUR So Flounder to be managed to allow 85% of the fish never being allowed to spawn, whether you want to see some "keeper" fish and even some you don't need to measure show up in your boat, or whether you want status quo.

My contact info is on the DENR site, but this it is if you care to use it ------ sobxl1@gmail.com and 252-532-3983.

My thanks again to this site for allowing me to post, and again, I beg you to participate, be informed, and make a difference for the fish in our State.

Good Fishing!!!



   
Quote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
Topic starter  

Additional information provided by Mr. Laughridge.

These are the average numbers of fish taken by commercial and recreational sectors from 2010 thru 2013, chosen to reflect the impact of the Sea Turtle ITP (the 2014 data should be available soon):

Commercial
Gillnet -------- 503,358
Pound net --- 280,959
Gigs ----------- 73,467
Other --------- 9,764
Total ---------- 867,547

Recreational
Hook & Line --- 149,783
Gigs -------------- 50,870
Total ------------- 200,653

*Used numbers of fish as this figure will most likely be used as opposed to pounds for management purposes
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The mid-point of a reduction between 25 & 60% is 42.5 (25 + 60 = 85 x .50 = 42.50). So just using this as a point of discussion, the simple math would suggest reducing each of the figures above by 42.5% and the problem is solved.

The MFC and all of y'all know the simple solution above is in how it is achieved between the user groups and the gear types in each user group. Here's where your ideas, thoughts and input come into play, and if it took this contentious crossroads to get y'all involved in the management of YOUR fisheries, the problem with So Flounder is a blessing in disguise.smile emoticon

But from the numbers above, please note that nothing has been said or done to date that will ban or stop either commercial or recreational fishing for So Flounder. Anyone who tells you that should be judged accordingly.

Are we most likely going to have to have restrictions before we can recover the stocks to having the ability to see keeper sized and larger fish in creels and available to both user groups and the public, yes!

We're paying for the mistakes made when prior Marine Fisheries Commissioners voted 8 to 1 against doing what the NCDMF suggested doing some years ago when the division recommended a a reduction harvest of approximately 38% and then the MFC approved and 18% and change reduction with the MFC chairman, Jimmy Johnson saying on the public record, and I paraphrase ------- "we're going ahead with a 20% reduction instead of a 40% reduction and hope the NCDMF scientists are wrong"!!!

Folks, we can't afford to "be wrong" again, so please be informed, be pissed off if it helps, but be involved! In the time it took you to read this post, you could have emailed all 9 Marine Fisheries Commission members, your Representative, Senator and County Commissioners your thoughts.smile emoticon

NC has some of the best data of any state, but you can force them to put it to better use than letting an MFC chair telling them "we hope you're wrong"!!!

Good Fishing!!!



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

That last sentence is bothersome. If NC has the best data then the rest of the states should be in trouble.
When the NC commercial fleet has so much they do not have to report legally, and it is known much is sold illegally~~~ it is impossible to be even close to the commercial catch.



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
Topic starter  

CC, agreed. I wondered about the 'best data' comment as well. The undisclosed catch and illegal sale should be a top priority for enforcement IMHO.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

Your ideas about commercial numbers aren't surprising to anyone reading here and neither would mine. What's your ideas on the rec data as reported? There's absolutely no reason to argue about the numbers they're touting and which is worse because those numbers are a fairy tale. Your assertion that there's fish being sold unreported is very true and I see it a lot inn my community but it's not the commercials usually who are doing it, more often it's unlicensed, low income individuals who are neither aware of or capable of giving a crap about this debate.



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
Topic starter  

What's your ideas on the rec data as reported?

I suspect there is actually very little or no useful data on rec catches. I have never reported, nor been required to report my catch.
The few times a year Marine Fisheries stops me they may assess my catch, but I don't believe they record or report it, although I could be wrong.

As for unreported sale, you may be correct. I guess there is no expectation of a fish house to not purchase or correctly record what is purchased anymore than there is for (some) commercial fishermen to be accurate in their numbers.

And again, I realize this is not everyone. You can't generalize about a huge group of people (whether it be CCA, recs, or comms) with any expectation of accuracy.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

I say that about unreported catches because I see it on the streets all the time, but even just common sense bears it all out. Sales made to individuals on the street are often made at well below market value which is the nature of black market "anything". Why would a licensed individual sell to the public for a reduced rate when they can go to the market and get market value. Their license allows them to do so. The only people with motive for selling illegally are the unlicensed people.



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

unlicensed, low income individuals who are neither aware of or capable of giving a crap about this debate.

:lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: :lmao: WTF ?



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
Topic starter  

The only people with motive for selling illegally are the unlicensed people.

Unless selling undersized, or out of season, or over their limit for a given period.

(One of) the problem is some individuals have shown they care only about personal profit at the expense of everything and everyone else, including adequately sustaining the species/resources.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

I say that about unreported catches because I see it on the streets all the time, but even just common sense bears it all out. Sales made to individuals on the street are often made at well below market value which is the nature of black market "anything". Why would a licensed individual sell to the public for a reduced rate when they can go to the market and get market value. Their license allows them to do so. The only people with motive for selling illegally are the unlicensed people.

Rec catches are only a guess also but not touted as great data. Those caught in Wilmington recently were licensed. No taxes paid on that sale if it were made. The comments some write/say that get reported indicate sales of under/over size, out of season sales are not that uncommon. Dealers cannot say it has been frozen if they have a trip ticket no one wants a record of. illegal sales is pone reason the commercial industry fights a JEA so hard. Many of those personal consumption catches are also sold. How many fish can a family eat that require unlimited gillnet catches? Those should be eliminated and restricted to rec limits.
The gillnet debate will go on until they are pulled completely at some point, probably not in my lifetime though. With the recs and hobbyists it is no wonder. If nets were pulled from the RCGL and personal consumption loophole removed from comms only the real professionals would remain. There would/should be little problem with pros. Someone is making money from those recs and hobbyists and it is not the pros who are having their income negatively impacted by them. Think about it from the dealers point ~ very low cost product to sell at premium price and enough of it to keep prices paid to pros low. Where does most of the money come from to pay state fishery lobbyist? Why must landings often be made in NC?



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

Why would a licensed individual sell to the public for a reduced rate when they can go to the market and get market value. Their license allows them to do so. The only people with motive for selling illegally are the unlicensed people.

Gee, ya think the chance to sell catch for cash,
@ a slight discount below retail instead of a
check @ wholesale value,

just might be a gamechanger ?

๐Ÿ™„



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
Topic starter  

Think about it from the dealers point ~ very low cost product to sell at premium price and enough of it to keep prices paid to pros low. Where does most of the money come from to pay state fishery lobbyist? Why must landings often be made in NC?

If ONLY there was a fisheries advisor whose spouse had a commercial license to BUY seafood. WOW!



   
ReplyQuote
QuickFix
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 245
 

FYI:

A few male southern flounders are mature between a length of 8 and 9 inches, 50% of the fish could spawn between 10 and 11 inches. All males are mature at a size of 13 inches total length. At 12 inches total length, about one-fifth (20%) of the female southern flounder are sexu- ally mature. Half the females about 14 inches long were able to spawn. All fishes 16 inches and larger in length were mature.

North Carolinaโ€™s rec- reational anglers harvested 236,648 pounds of southern flounder in 2002. That same year, recreational gig landings were estimated to be 361,539 pounds, about 1.5 times the hook and line landings.

Now that is interesting. I wonder what true rec numbers are in more current years!!



   
ReplyQuote
Art Patelos
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 25
 

Used to fish with my Dad who manufactured fishing lures, we jigged up plenty of Spanish, Flounder and Grey Trout every time we went 50-60 Spanish, 100 Trout, 20 or 30 Flounder Depending on the time of year Etc.. then Dad wanted to also drop Gill Nets, I could not believe it, but he did, usually 2to 3 100 yd nets, of course he had a commercial license now we we were filling the boat actually filling 50 gal. trash cans with fish, this was 1966- 1968 time period, Case in point -Spanish- Party Over, Grey Trout- Party Over, Flounder Party over and more to come, This is what happens when there have been no regulations in the past , Now, Over Regulation, Accept smaller catches or you will be able to keep one Flounder of any size (lucky You andI)



   
ReplyQuote
Art Patelos
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 25
 

Low Income, I think Not, Not aware of Legislation, I think not, Low Education I think not, I Gave up my dads commercial license by choice. I have a right to my opinion the same as you. And frankly some of your comments are without merit as far as I am concerned. Either quit insulting people you do not know or don't speak when adults are talking, Thank you



   
ReplyQuote
Share: